The San Francisco 49ers are at a pivotal juncture as the 2026 offseason approaches, with a significant number of defensive athletes whose contracts are concluding. Following a campaign that saw them reach the divisional playoffs but also expose defensive vulnerabilities, the team is set on enhancing this unit. This comprehensive overview meticulously assesses each impending defensive free agent, assigning priority levels for their potential return. The evaluation spans from players considered unlikely to be retained to those deemed essential for the team's future success, underscoring the critical choices that lie ahead for the 49ers' front office.
Addressing the defensive end position, Robert Beal Jr. has not met expectations since his 2023 draft selection, struggling to secure consistent playing time, which signals a low probability of his return. Similarly, Tarron Jackson, sidelined by a neck injury during training camp, is not expected to be a priority for re-signing, despite the possibility of a future, non-priority deal. At safety, Jason Pinnock's tenure appears tied to former coach Robert Saleh, and his 'big nickel' role is likely to be upgraded, making his return improbable except perhaps on a minimal contract without a significant role. Yetur Gross-Matos, a defensive lineman, presents a dilemma due to persistent knee and hamstring issues. While familiar with the system, his injury history places him on a low priority for re-signing, as the team seeks more reliable options.
Linebacker Curtis Robinson, however, stands out for his dedication and community involvement, having been a two-time Walter Payton Man of the Year nominee. His contributions on special teams and as an injury fill-in suggest a higher chance of retention, though not as an immediate priority given his depth chart position. Garret Wallow's exceptional playoff performance against the Philadelphia Eagles could sway his re-signing priority, contingent on how much value the team places on that single outing, likely resulting in an inexpensive, non-guaranteed deal. Clelin Ferrell, another defensive end, tied for the team lead in sacks despite limited appearances, highlighting both his potential and the team's anemic pass rush. He might be considered for a veteran depth role, but the defensive line requires more substantial fortification. Kevin Givens, an undrafted defensive lineman who carved out a role since 2019, saw reduced playing time in 2025, indicating the team's readiness to move past what has been an 'okay' rotational piece, aiming to outgrow the need for him.
In the secondary, Chase Lucas, a restricted free agent (RFA), is unlikely to receive a tender offer. While he could contribute on special teams and as a reserve nickel corner, he is not a high-priority retention. Luke Gifford's fate as a linebacker largely depends on special teams coordinator Brant Boyer's assessment; otherwise, his subpar defensive performance makes him dispensable. Sam Okuayinonu, a defensive end, surprisingly holds a higher-than-expected priority due to the team's pass-rush deficiencies. His familiarity with the system and occasional effectiveness might secure his return as a rotational piece, reflecting the team's current limitations. Eric Kendricks, an experienced linebacker, was a valuable late-season addition despite his best years being behind him. He could fill a starting Sam LB role if no better options emerge, but the team is open to exploring younger talent. Finally, defensive linemen Jordan Elliott and Kalia Davis both fall into the medium priority category. Elliott offers a reliable rotational option, while the younger, less experienced Davis is coming off his best year and is also seen as a rotational piece in the rebuilt defensive line.
The San Francisco 49ers are embarking on a critical rebuilding phase for their defense, necessitated by numerous impending free agents and a desire for stronger performance. The assessment of each player's value, from rotational depth to potential starters, underscores a calculated approach to roster management. While some players like Curtis Robinson offer valuable cultural contributions, others such as Robert Beal Jr. and Tarron Jackson are likely to be let go as the team seeks significant upgrades. The decisions made this offseason will profoundly shape the 49ers' defensive capabilities and their competitiveness in the seasons to come, aiming to balance experience with new talent to forge a more formidable unit.